"Sneaky Peaks"
"Electric" Inhabitants In this article we will explore another practical application of the "audio" control of scale lighting.
The "Electric" Inhabitants illusion not only serves as interior lighting for your buildings, but it also adds the extra dimension of activity and movement within your structures, as well! This effect really works, and will spellbind everyone who witnesses any building into which it is installed... and it is sooo easy to do! Here is a bright idea. Light bulbs are rated in watts, and so are audio amplifiers! A light bulb lights when it sees enough voltage to make the filament glow. The bulb does not know, or care, where that voltage comes from, it could be a wall outlet, a transformer or power pack plugged into a wall outlet, or it could be a battery. It could even be an audio amplifier... Miniature lamps (or micro-lamps, as they are sometimes referred to in scale sizes) have a wide range in which they operate, from a dim glimmer to startling brilliance. With the right audio tracks, you can "animate" the light between a pair of lamps to express a number of illusions for you! With the right audio tracks, you can make lamps appear to be the inhabitants in a building... That's why we went into the recording studio... to build "tracks" for your railroad! The tracks are "ready to run", and free for the downloading. We built the SAME "Electric" FX system you will learn how to build here. We tweaked the soundtracks in the studio until they "looked" good on that system, and then transcribed them into sound files for you. We'll show you step by step how to download these soundtracks and create cassette tapes that will look absolutely real in your new "Electric"ally Inhabited building(s)! Even if you need to buy all of the parts, the whole thing will cost less than twenty-five bucks! This is not Audio-animatronics (see: Enginear's Notes). Although by today's standards audio-animatronics control was fairly simple, it could not hold a candle to the elegant simplicity of "Electric" FX! What we will explore here is infinitely more direct! It is a pure form of control that can be ridiculously simple and inexpensive to apply, once you have the audio programming! And it is much more expressive and effective than ANY of its predecessors ever were! Be sure to look through the Designer's Notes too. This series is in three main parts:
Part One: The Soundtracks In this part you will learn how to create cassette loops that will serve as the program material in your "Electric" Inhabitants FX system...
"The Magic's in the Sound" The secret behind the magic of "Electric" lighting effects is in the audio program itself. An extremely unconventional sounding, but appropriate "looking" dedicated audio program has been developed for the application described here. What you will need:
What you'll do: Downloading the files... Downloading is easy. Go to the download page to find the "Electric" FX files you want for your model railroad. Click on the titles to begin downloading to your hard drive. You might wish to create a new folder into which you will save these files, this can make things less confusing later. These files are 16 bit, 44.1khz sample rate stereo sound files and are therefore several megabytes long. You may wish to schedule your download for a time when the internet is less congested (ie, late night, overnight, or early morning). In any event, be prepared to wait awhile for each file to download completely. WARNING! THESE FILES ARE DESIGNED TO BE SEEN, AND NOT HEARD! TURN THE VOLUME DOWN BEFORE YOU PLAY THEM, IT CAN BE UNNERVING! Set-up for transcription... Once you have collected all of the files onto your computer you are ready to set-up for transcription to cassette. The set-up is straightforward. You will need to make the stereo audio connection between your computer and your cassette recorder by connecting the left and right audio line level outputs of your computer or sound card to the left and right audio line level (or "record in") inputs of your cassette recorder with a standard component stereo phono patch cable (most likely a male RCA to male RCA pair). Matching left and right channels between the machines is not important, as long as both channels are connected. Open the sound file in any application that can play the file WITHOUT converting it. Hit the space bar (or the play button on the screen) and listen through the file in its entirety. Watch the counter if there is one, or a clock, so that you can recognize the end when you get to it. Repeat this process with each of the files you have downloaded as this will help you to make some of the editing decisions in the next few steps. At some point you must decide what type of cassette tape format you will mix down into; either an answering machine continuous loop, or conventional two sided cassette. Each type has positive and negative aspects associated with it. The phone answer machine loop tape is easier and faster to create, which is a positive in that you can get to playing it sooner. It is much shorter in length so it takes less time and fewer passes to fill it with sound. With FX tracks, it is not as obvious that the tape is looping (repeating), so the shorter tape lenght is more acceptable in this applicaton. Another plus with the loop cassette is that once you start it playing you can forget about it until you are ready to stop it (it will just keep going continuously, no rewinding or flipping it over). On the negative side, the continuous loop cassette will likely be loaded with lower quality tape. This is not too critical since "Electric" FX are not heard. Things like tape hiss (tape noise) or minor distortion will be inaudible. Still, lower quality tape will wear out sooner resulting in poorer reproduction, potential dropouts and potential tape failure (a tape being "eaten" by your player). It will also wear out sooner because it plays the same piece of tape more times in any given time period (putting you right back here, REtranscribing sooner). The longest loop cassette I have ever seen is four minutes! The standard 30, 45 or 60 minute cassette is probably the best way to go if you have some patience during the recording process, and if you don't mind flipping the tape once in a while (If you choose to use an auto-reverse deck, this would not be a problem). You can buy longer running 90 minute cassettes, but this is a thinner tape and more susceptible to becoming a cheap player's lunch! In general, standard cassettes are loaded with higher quality tape which will likely make a better recording (quieter, less likely to go into distortion, etc.). Additionally, you can create a more pleasing "composition" within the longer format, with more quiet moments or variation which will appear completely unpredictable. Finally, this format will last longer than loops in that it will only be "handled" by your player once or twice in an hour. In either event, you should consider making a master cassette from which you can make copies for use on your railroad. This eliminates the need to go back through the recording process described here when (not if) your tape wears out. It is easy to make duplicate tapes on any dubbing deck. A dubbing deck is the kind with two cassette machines in one unit, many ghetto blasters have this capability and will usually do a suitable job for our purposes, if you do everything described below.
Transcription to cassette... Ok, you have chosen a cassette type, you've familiarized yourself with your new audio files and you are plugged in and just about ready to start recording... but hang on! Before you load that cassette into the recorder, read through this check list first!
OK, you are about to make your first mix-down pass. If you have the first sound file cued up (ready to play) in your computer and a cassette loaded in your recorder, and if the recorder is in record mode AND on pause, you are ready to go. Hit the space bar (or click the play button on screen) and then take the recorder out of pause, in that order. When the file is finished playing, the computer should automatically stop. You should drop the recorder back into pause JUST BEFORE the file is finished playing on the computer, if you want a continuous appearance to the effect. Re-cue the sound file. Hit play on the computer, and then the pause button on the deck and repeat the process above. You will keep repeating this sequence until you have completely filled up your cassette tape. It is just that simple... that boring, that tedious, but that simple! Here are a couple of tips to help make your mastering go faster. If you have taken the advice above and are making a master tape for duplication to working copies for use on your railroad, you can fill only side A of your master tape. Then when you are duplicating you can just flip the copy over, rewind the master, and fill the B side of your copy with the same program. This will not only save time in the mastering process, but also saves time when playing the copy on your railroad system. When the cassette finishes playing through your "Electric" FX system, you simply flip it over and begin playing again immediately, rather than waiting while a single sided cassette rewinds in order to replay it. This also cuts down on the amount of "wasted" tape handling (rewind wear and tear) to your cassette copy. If you are planning to insert a quiet space just let the recorder continue to record for a few seconds while you are cueing up for the next pass (keep your ears pealed for computer clicks or pops when files are cueing). I know at first it seems strange to have lighting that goes on and off around your layout, all by itself. "It ain't natural", and yet, it is kind of cool too. You are going to have some dropouts with normal tape operation anyway, and it is fun to watch visitors react/interact when they do notice. A period of silence is easy to do and really adds character to the final performance. And, it is an easy way to fill up a long tape!
Part Two: The "Audio" System In this part you will learn how ridiculously cheap and simple it is to create... Figure 1 Not much to it, is there? What you will need:
The decisions you will make at this point will be based on several factors, all having to do with the nature of your specific railroad.You might consider the following: Pike size? If your layout is smaller than 4 'x8 ', a single stereo system is likely all you will ever need. Larger layouts will generally be best served by a distributed approach, or multiple "basic" stereo system installations. (You could go wild and install multiple distributed systems, my favorite!) "Basic" stereo system? (see: Figure 1, above) This is the easiest and cheapest way to go, and therefore an excellent first project. If you are pleased with the results, you can always install additional single stereo systems later (my second favorite approach!). Distributed system? Virtually identical to a single system, with three exceptions: 1) You will run a pair of busses (left and right channel) around your layout, "tapping voltage" at various points by splicing into these busses. 2) You must use "matched" lamps for this. 3) You will likely need an amplified system. This approach can be better on larger layouts and club railroads (see: Figure 2, and Figure 3, below). There IS a limit to how many lamps you can safely attach in parallel to tiny headphone outputs (generally rated between .5 watt, and 3 watts). This varies with players. You may need an amp or car stereo deck with amps to drive more than two 1.5v lamps! Which lamps? If you are going to build a single stereo system, and are going to use small 1.5v lamps (for example, Circuitron # 800-7411-02, 13ma., pkg. of 2), you may be able to use the headphone output of your new cassette player (see the Enginear's Notes regarding voltage vs wattage for specific technical information). Try them out together, first. If, on the other hand, a distributed approach with an external amplifier is right for your railroad, you might try 12v lamps (for example, Circuitron #800-7440-06, 30ma, pkg. of 6 ). In either case, I suggest you go for a single "reference lamp" throughout you layout for more predictable results. Ask Circuitron for their "Mitey Lites" miniature lamp catalog, they have a large selection, and are always willing to help you figure out the right choice for your particular application. As long as your system can drive them, any pair of lamps WILL work, but it is always best to work with matched lamp pairs. How many systems? Don't laugh, two basic systems can more than double the fun and interest of this effect! Once you have gone through the downloading and mastering processes, you are only $14.95, or less, away from your next complete system. When you see the results, and observe others responding with smiles, multiple systems will start to look like a pretty good idea. Also, unless they are started at exactly the same time, multiple systems never link up exactly, so that you have a constantly varying "mix" within scenes and around your pike! Way nifty! Go to Walmart or K-mart or any mart that sells ridiculously cheap cassette player/headphone bubble packs, and purchase one (or more)! You should not need to spend more than $14.95 plus tax, or you should probably try another mart. I literally did this. I went to Walmart and asked a clerk for "the ridiculously cheap cassette player/headphone bubble packs", and he pointed me to the end of isle 14... during that sale, they were $5.00 plus tax! While you are there, if your cassette player doesn't come with one, look for a "wall wart" (a step-down transformer that plugs into the wall and your deck). If you buy them separately, make sure that the transformer delivers the correct voltage for your particular cassette player. By the way, you should be able to use almost ANY cassette player for "Electric" FX, as long as it can deliver enough VOLTAGE (see: Enginear's Notes). If you have an old ghetto blaster, home stereo deck or car stereo deck you can allocate to the task, you might be able to use it! Always clean and demagnetize the heads and tape path of any machine (see above). If you choose to use a home stereo tape deck, it will likely have a headphone output for which you may need a stereo 1/4" phone to 1/8" mini phone jack adapter (available at Radio Shack, number 274-367). If you choose to use a car stereo unit, you will need a 12 vdc, 3 (or more) amp power supply (Radio Shack, number 22-504), or old train power pack to deliver 12vdc power to your system. You should use the car stereo player's amplified outputs to drive your lighting system, just set the volume carefully! I used a 150 watt P.A. amplifier (because it was handy) to drive one little 12v doll house lamp as a "reference monitor" when preparing the "Electric" FX soundtracks. As long as there were no pops or clicks, such as transients from turning the Mac off while the amp was still on (which I did... twice), the little lamp performed flawlessly. The point is that you can use an amplifier that is over-rated, as long as you realize that there is a much higher risk of frying lamps! Just turn it down (again, see: Enginear's Notes). The little disposable decks mentioned above are a better choice if you will be using 1.5v lamps. With their larger built-in amplifiers, car decks are better suited to the tasks of "Electric" FX (or Point Source FX audio described elsewhere in the site). If your particular deck has auto-reverse, all the better, you'll never have to flip a tape over (listen for pops or clicks in the audio output when the deck reverses). If you do not already have some suitable wire laying around, you will have to go to the local hardware or electronics store to find it. If your layout is small, or if you only intend to use "Electric" Inhabitants in one place on your layout, you may not need additional wire. The headphone plug and wires that come with the cassette player may be enough for your installation. Any small gauge (ga) two conductor wire (18 ga to 20 ga) will work for the short lengths and low voltages involved in these installations. If you will use a distributed system with several lamps tapped along a buss over 15 feet in length, you can buy 18 - 16 ga. (or even 14 ga.) zip cord for the busses. If your cheapo cassette player came with headphones, they are probably disposable. You can use the cable from them to feed your system (maybe you could use the speaker elements for Environmentals?). Many headphone cables have a small square nut that is there to keep the two wires from separating. If you want to separate the wires, slide this nut down toward the mini-phone jack in order to achieve the maximum separation. You should be able to just peel the two wires apart all the way down to the nut/plug. On larger pikes, or in larger scales with 12v lamps, an alternative system could be a car stereo cassette deck with built-in amps (see: Figure 2), and/or RCA type line level outputs that can drive a larger external amplifier (see: Figure 3). A 30-watt per channel amp "should" be able to provide all the firepower necessary for all but the largest (club) layouts (see: Enginear's Notes). An added benefit of the car stereo deck is that most of them are auto-reverse, allowing hands off operation (no flipping the tape over). Another option is to use a cassette ghetto blaster with built-in amps (see: Figure 4). If you can afford one with enough voltage to drive some lamps (see: Enginear's Notes), it can be an all-in-one package that just plugs into the wall. You will have to modify it by opening it up and disconnecting the internal speakers (which you can save for "Point Source" duty). You will then have to "break out" the amplifier leads in order to feed the busses to your layout. You could also feed lamps or an external amp with the headphone output, but that will invariably "defeat" the internal amps (it is either/or here). WARNING! Some headphone amps may not put put enough voltage to be able to drive lamps! If you want to use the headphone outputs of a player to drive lighting directly, always do a quick check by hanging a lamp on the output, first! WARNING! Some cassette players pop, click, or throw out a sub-harmonic when you start or stop them! This can really "rip" lamps! With a tape in your player, listen carefully with headphones as you hit the play and stop buttons. If you hear anything at all, institute a policy right now to turn the volume completely down, EVERY TIME, BEFORE you start or stop tape. The Hot Rod System. Depending upon the voltage the amplifiers in the deck can deliver, and the lamps you use, you can drive from 2 - 12 or more lamps from busses, with a system like this! The amplified outputs should be bussed with 16 - 18ga. zip or "lamp" cable (For runs of over twenty feet, use 14ga. wire to reduce line loss).
The Luxury System. Depending upon the size amplifier and lamps you use, you can drive 24 or more lamps on each channel with this system! The amplified outputs should be bussed with 16ga. zip or "lamp" cable (For runs of over twenty feet, use 14ga. wire to reduce line loss). The Y adapter cable is available from Radio Shack, #42-7425, 1/8" stereo to 2 male phono, for $4.49.
Fig. 4 The All-in-One System. This is a good way to go if you can afford to buy, or "retire", a ghetto blaster with enough firepower to drive a few lamps!
If your layout is small, or in a small scale, you may not have to do anything else to prepare your system for installation! Jump right into Part Three!
Part Three: Installation Lets explore some ways to apply and conceal your "Electric" Inhabitants...
What you will need:
What you'll do: You can hardly go wrong installing "Electric" Inhabitants... it is literally almost impossible! What you WILL do at first, is blow up lamps... it is almost impossible NOT to (at least until you get a feel for it)! For this reason, you should always have plenty of spare lamps on hand, and you should always set-up and test your new system with "bare bulbs" (lamps that have not yet been installed into buildings). Although there is really no wrong way to do it (if it looks good to you), I have included some art and a "check list" of suggestions for you to look through, to guide you in the right directions. Look through the following, it should be helpful...
"Electric" Inhabitants Installation Check List:
About the placement of Lamps...
The above examples demonstrate some basic starting points for your lamp positioning experimentation. Each example creates a different result within, and around the "inhabited" building!
Above are the basic component parts of any light projector (or any lighting device). Below, are the same components as they appear in a typical professional theatrical lighting device. Directly below that, are the exact same components as they might appear in YOUR layout...
The basic components in a typical theatrical lighting device.
In the above "projector", the lamp is a standard 1.5v or 12v miniature light, the aperture is a window or door in a scale building, and the screen is the scenery or ground around the building (a reflector is optional).
In the side view (above, left), you can see the construction of a shadow projector (the lamps can be pulled into the tube to "crop" the lighting). The lamps can actually be enclosed inside of the projector (above, right), projecting through a hole cut out of the side of the tubing (a lid or "cap" can be soldered on the top, to eliminate light leakage). The enclosed version works even better in a building that already has "static" interior lighting. In either application, the solid copper wire is "adjusted" to optimize the effect in each building. Multiple wires can be used to create a more complex shadow, up to a point...
In the top view (above), you see the relationships of the basic components. The lamps are right next to each other, the distance to the wire determines the size of the shadow cast (closer is bigger). The distance of the entire projector from the "screen" also affects the size of the cast shadow (farther is bigger), as well as the amount of movement of the shadow (farther is more). When lamp (a) is brighter, the shadow will be cast in position (a), and vice verse.
A simple "snoot" reflector housing is a piece of brass (or aluminum) tubing. By pulling the lamp into the housing, you can narrow the pattern projected. If you choose to use brass tubing, a short piece of solid copper wire soldered onto the tubing can make mounting and aiming your "lighting device" quick and easy! If you are using aluminum tubing, a piece of copper wire can still be epoxy'ed on to the tubing for installation and adjustment purposes (sand a rough spot on the tubing where you will epoxy). Just drill a hole in the model and insert the wire, then you can point the light in any direction by bending the wire.
You "aim" and "crop" the light by rotating the tubing...
WARNING! Some cassette players pop, click, or throw out a sub-harmonic when you start or stop them! This can really "rip" lamps! With a tape in your player, listen carefully with headphones as you hit the play and stop buttons. If you hear anything at all, institute a policy right now to turn the volume completely down, EVERY TIME, BEFORE you start or stop tape.
Designer's Notes: A part of you will want to get started ASAP. I do not blame you! But IF you want to get creative with your new medium read on! The more you know, the more fun it is! After all, that is why you came here. You are creating an illusion, the illusion that there are actually inhabitants in the buildings in a scene. The more you understand about how the trick works, the better you (and your layout) will perform it! And, there are more illusions that you can create with the same soundtracks... read on.
About audio control of lighting...
About scale lighting...
FAQ&A: "All my lights go out when my deck auto-reverses (or crosses the splice point)". I recommend doing a tight editing job, and living with the "free animation" of your lights momentarily blinking off and on every once-in-a-while, but... There are several solutions to this. You can have more than one FX system. At today's prices, you could be running two, staggered cheapo cassette headphone-driven systems on a smaller layout for under $30. Or, you can insure that by design every scene has enough constant or circuitry controlled lighting that the dropout is not missed. Or, you might be able to drive one amplifier with two decks started at different times. Or, you can just live with the momentary blackouts... they are very short, and they can be dramatic or fun sometimes. After all, lanterns do "blink" in the wind, or flicker when the kerosene is getting low. Even electric lighting shudders or blinks, from time to time. This free animation adds a feeling of activity and magic as things happen all by themselves! Here is a suggestion for recording your continuous loop cassettes in a way that will minimize these "black-outs". Before you record, look for the splice on the open edge of a continuous loop cassette tape, if you do not see it, shuttle the tape forward until you do. When you have found the splice, load the cassette back into the recorder, put the recorder into record, run it forward a few seconds and put it on pause. If you have a one-minute cassette, record for ninety-seconds and then hit pause again before taking the recorder out of the record mode (if it is a two minute loop, record for three, a three minute loop for four, etc.). You are deliberately recording "over" the splice and start points! This will minimize the drop out across the splice itself, and at the start/stop point too. Or, If you absolutely, positively cannot tolerate momentary dropouts in your "Electric" inhabitants, you can "mix" two cassette tapes together within a Dual Cassette Ghetto Blaster (see: Figure 5, below). Any delay between the two tapes will cover the splice, or start/stop dropouts on both. Just make two copies of the same tape. You will have to disconnect the internal speakers (possibly by snipping the wires), and "break out" the leads through a circulation vent (or hole you drill yourself). I have seen suitable dual cassette ghetto blasters for under $40.00! If you get a more expensive ghetto blaster with auto reverse, the two tapes will shuttle at different times... if you start them at different times. I have seen suitable auto-reverse dual cassette ghetto blasters for $79.95. I have to be honest here, I have not tried this with "Electric" Inhabitants, yet. It is possible that the two tapes could cancel the effect at certain times, but this would result in a constant lighting effect (or subdued inhabitant effect), and should still be interesting, in its own way... Figure 5 This is not a bad approach, everything is built-in. Just start the two tapes separately. Always check first by putting a tape in both sides and hitting both play buttons, not all dual cassette players will play both tapes at the same time! The cheaper ones usually do (it takes less circuitry to leave both decks attached to the amps at all times). I suppose you could also use digital delay lines (DDL) in-line with each channel, or two cassette players "mixed down into a single amplifier through Y adapters in an effort to eliminate dropouts. I must admit though, I have never tried either of these... I like the occasional flickering!
FAQ&A: "But what if I know the deck I'm using for playback will have noise reduction decoding, can't I use noise reduction when I make the copy, and get even more dynamic range?" Good question! The answer is "maybe"...under ideal circumstances, the 3 - 6 db or so of additional headroom might be noticeable. But brighter is not necessarily better, you could start burning out bulbs. In fact, if you are using 1.5v lamps, you should never use NR. I had to do 7:1 compression processing to a program originally created for commercial applications, in order to squish it down into the smaller scale lamps. They have less "headroom", the lowest parts of the program were invisible, while the peaks were ripping filaments. You cannot go over 0 VU no matter what, and the noise floor no longer matters with electric fire FX! You simply do not need it! Noise reduction systems compress the signal onto a tape track; some systems do this in several separate frequency bands! Then they expand it back up upon playback. Given the nature of the "Electric" Inhabitants program, NR could wreak havoc, or it could be splendid... I wouldn't know, I have never tried it. If you want to go through the extra steps, you can try it, carefully, in your own application. My guess is that you will not be able to see a difference. If your player has a smaller amp, you might think you need a "hot" tape just to fire the amp hard enough. Just record it hot, and try driving the amplifier into clipping (see: Enginear's Notes). By the way, if the headphone output is not strong enough to drive lamps by itself, you can use it to drive an external amp. Just start with the volume all the way down, and turn it up slowly. The headphone amp may not be able to drive a lamp by itself, but it can easily overdrive the inputs to an external amplifier so keep the volume low. WARNING! Always eject the tape when the player is "parked" after use. Many players, especially car stereo decks, mechanically keep the capstan pressed up against the pinch roller when the power is turned off to the deck. Over time this can leave dents in the rubber pinch roller creating a terrible wow or flutter. The only fix for this is to replace the pinch roller. Be safe, and eject the tape after each operating session. This may not be a problem on many walkman and ghetto blaster type players, but check first to be safe!
Enginear's Notes: The more you understand about what you are seeing and doing, the better your system will look to everyone, including you! These Enginear's Notes are designed to give you the background that will enable you to optimize many aspects of your installation. Yes, some of it is dry and technical. And, yes it may not be essential in order for your system work. Scale lighting is very forgiving, and in general, any lighting effect is still better than NO lighting effect. But so much creative effort went into the design of your soundtracks, that it would be a shame for you not to get the most back out of them. This is NOT Audio-animatronics! You cannot hear Audio-animatronics. Audio-animatronics had
nothing to do with audible sound. It was a simple way to synchronize
multiple animated events, with multiple tones on the same tape.
An audio tone was used to turn a circuit on, or off (called an
analog movement). Specifically, a sympathetic vibrating reed
relay switch closed an electrical circuit when an appropriate
pitched tone was present on a tape track. Multiple tones on each
track, and multiple tracks allowed for control and synchronization
of many events. Synchronization of tape decks allowed synchronization
of these events with the audible sound. This original Disney
animation control system has long since been replaced with microprocessor
control where feed back information reports to the computer so
that it can control speed relative to exact positioning (called
a digital movement).
Tech Notes from "That Dang" Dale: The power going into a lamp is determined by the applied voltage and by the lamps resistance. How much amp power is enough? .5 Watts is plenty if we're talking about an amp that can drive 8 Ohms - (see table 1, below) an amplifier that can deliver .28 Watts (1.5 Volts RMS into 8 Ohms) can drive up to 14 of the 1.5 lamps. Walkman outputs may be for 40 Ohm headphones or higher however, and the voltage may also be too low. If an output is able to handle a 40 Ohm load, it should be able to handle 3 of the cited 1.5 V lamps in parallel. Voltage may be a bit low, but see the note on clipping and RMS values below. It looks like an amp rated at 20 Watts/channel into 8 Ohms is best for 12 Volt lamps, even half a Watt per channel is more than plenty for the 1.5 Volt lamps. The amplifier power rating says two things - it tells us the minimum amount of voltage that is available with the amp driven to full power, and it tells us how many lamps we can run. If the amp can deliver the same voltage into 4 Ohms instead of 8, it can run twice as many lamps. For folks with amps putting out more than 1.5 volts but less than 12 volts RMS we might suggest groups of lamps in series. Not having a great deal of extra voltage available reduces the chances of blown lamps when someone pops in a Van Halen tape or turns the wrong knob...
How can I estimate the maximum output voltage and power of a portable or car stereo? A good rule of thumb is figure on the maximum peak-to-peak output voltage of a single amplifier being about 2 Volts less than the available power supply voltage. The RMS value for sine wave output is that peak to peak value times .354 (one over twice the square-root of two). Based on that, an amplifier using a 6 Volt supply can probably deliver enough voltage for using 1.5 Volt lamps. The power output into 8 Ohms is simply the RMS voltage squared, divided by the 8 Ohms resistance. Standard or bridge-mode car stereos/amps cannot put out enough voltage for driving 12 Volt lamps except when the better amplifiers running on step-up switching power supplies are used. Simply put, the low power supply voltages from batteries operation limit output voltages to relatively low levels. To get a bit more power at minimal cost, many automotive amps actually use a pair of amplifiers bridge-connected for each channel to double the output voltage (quadrupling the power). One sign that you have a bridge amplifier is that none of the speaker wires can be grounded. Bridging brings the output from about 2 Watts to about 8 Watts into an 8 Ohm load. It is common to use 4 Ohm speakers paralleled to 2 Ohms to increase power more by increasing the current delivered. The same output voltage across 2 Ohms corresponds to four times as much power as it would across 8 Ohms. Since the bridge amplifier is generally just one low-cost integrated circuit, bridge amps are commonly used in basic car stereos. A separate booster amp that is just another direct-battery-powered bridge amp won't produce any more power. For us, the ability to handle the current associated with a 2 Ohm load just means we can parallel more lamps, but the higher wattage figure doesn't mean there is enough voltage for 12 Volt lamps. By rating the amplifiers into 2 Ohms, combining the output figures for both channels, testing an amp on a 14 Volt or so supply, and perhaps driving it into clipping, some units may have claimed output figures of 65-125 Watts! They still don't put out enough to properly drive our 1/3 Watt 12 Volt lamps... The moral? When comparing amps use only the single-channel into 8-Ohms low-distortion ratings.
What about over driven amps? It should be noted that lamps don't care about distortion... just the RMS voltage. The RMS voltage for a square wave is 1.41 (square root of two) times that of a sine wave having the same peak value. So an amplifier that can't quite put out a lamp's rated voltage as a sine wave may still give acceptable results if driven into clipping. Since more RMS voltage is available with an amp driven into heavy clipping, there is that much more reason not to use amplifiers more powerful than needed to deliver the required voltage. (RMS or DC voltage value squared, divided by load resistance)
Here are calculations/tables that will be illuminating when it comes to amplifier output voltage requirements, and the loading that the suggested lamps present...
1.5v lamps (for example, Circuitron # 800-7411-02) 1.5V * .013A = .0195 Watt 1.5V / .013A = 115 Ohms Max # of lamps on buss to avoid going under 8 ohm load, about 14 Max # of lamps on buss to avoid going under 4 ohm load, about 28 Max # of lamps on buss to avoid going under 2 ohm load, about 57
12v lamps (for example, Circuitron #800-7440-06) 12V * .030A = .36 Watt 12V / .030A = 400 Ohms Max # of lamps on buss to avoid going under 8 ohm load, about 50 Max # of lamps on buss to avoid going under 4 ohm load, about 100 Max # of lamps on buss to avoid going under 2 ohm load, about 200
About Portables and Car Stereos... The stereos and non-switching-supply amps really don't put out enough for 12 Volt lamps, but the bridge-mode units should just be usable if driven into heavy clipping. Based on the above table, an amp that can deliver 36 Watts into 4 Ohms (call it 40 Watts) could drive 100 of the 12 V lamps per channel. Note that an amp rated at 40 Watts into 8 Ohms is NOT suggested. The higher voltage associated with that amplifier would increase risks of accidental lamp burnout. If you have an amp that can put out much more than the required voltage, putting lamps in series to increase the voltage requirement can reduce the burnout risks associated with excessive headroom. For handling more lamps than a 40 Watt into 4 Ohm amp can handle I would suggest using multiple amps of the same type instead of a more powerful amp. That would avoid the riskier higher voltages. |